Wilmington Faith & Values

Blogs » Viewpoints

VIEWPOINTS: Do animals have souls?

Show Caption |

Writer Jana Greene's dog, Emmie. Credit: Photo by Jana Greene

Amanda.Greene@ReligionNews.com

TALK BACK | SEND A LINK | SEND A TIP | SEND PHOTOS OR VIDEOS CORRECT THIS STORY

Is it instinct or a spiritual self that links an animal to its owner?

When your dog comes to lay its head in your lap when you're having a rough day, how does it know that's the right thing to do?

The question about how deeply animals feel or have a spiritual being is an interesting one in theology.

Some theologians say no, animals don't have souls because the Bible says man was created to rule over the animals.

Catholic theology says animals have souls in the sense that they have the principle of life, but animals don't have spiritual souls. Animals, in this view, can't make moral decisions. But in 1990, Pope John Paul II made a statement affirming "the animals possess a soul and men must love and feel solidarity with our smaller brethren." He also said animals are "fruit of the creative action of the Holy Spirit and merit respect" and that they are "as near to God as men are."

Mormons believe in souls, an afterlife, salvation and resurrection for animals.

This is an interesting piece from a Muslim convert pondering that faith's view about animals and souls.

What do you believe? Do animals have souls?

Amanda Greene: 910-520-3958 or

Find WilmingtonFAVS on Twitter (@iwritereligion or @WilmFAVS), Facebook, Tumblr and Pinterest.

Topics: Culture, Family & Relationships, Science
Beliefs: Interfaith
Tags: animals, souls, viewpoints

Responses to This Viewpoint

‘An animal’s soul is pure and untainted’

"We can theorize, we can speculate, but wouldn’t it be nice to know even after death, you get to see, not only your ancestors, but also the animals you so very loved during your lifetime?"
More | Comments (0)

No souls, but animals must be treated with respect and dignity

"For those of us who hold our morality as completely centered in, and derived from, our humanity, the treatment and valuing of the non-human life with which we share this planet is at the very core of how we assess and evaluate our basic moral worth."
More | Comments (1)

Animals ‘a marvel of creation.’

Each individual identity, however small, is a marvel of creation.
More | Comments (0)

The holiness of old dogs

"But the holiest attribute Emmie displays may be the most subtle.  It is the way she humbly seeks my face.  When offered a treat, her gaze is on my hand (nor the delicious bone I’m holding).  No, she is starting at the acceptance in my expression, her big, chocolate drop eyes searching to read my face."
More | Comments (0)

Comments

  1. “That’s why I don’t think there’s any comparison between the present hard times and the coming good times.  The created world itself can hardly wait for what’s coming next.  Everything in creation is being more or less held back.  God reins it in until both creation and all the creatures are ready and can be released at the same moment into the glorious times ahead.  Meanwhile, they joyful anticipation deepens.” - Romans 8:18-21 (MSG)

Add Your Comment

If the stomach is blue, what colour is it?

Sign In



Forgot Password?

You also can sign in with Facebook or Twitter if you've connected your account to them.

Sign In Using Facebook

Sign In Using Twitter